Safety vs privacy: How domestic-help platforms are building a two-way support system

A
sig ifica t
demog aphic
of
the
se vice
p ovide s
at
these
platfo ms
a d
the
co sume s
comp ise
of
wome .

I dia’s
i sta t
domestic
help
eco omy
is
expa di g
faste .
As
app-based
platfo ms
p omise
clea e s,
cooks
a d
household
wo ke s
withi
mi utes.
Howeve ,
the
eal
co test
he e
is
o
lo ge
just
about
speed,
co ve ie ce
o
p ici g.
It
is
i c easi gly
about
t ust.A
sig ifica t
demog aphic
of
the
se vice
p ovide s
at
these
platfo ms
a d
the
co sume s
comp ise
of
wome .Fo
yea s,
domestic
wo k
i
I dia
has
ope ated
th ough
i fo mal
eighbou hood
etwo ks,
wo d-of-mouth
efe als
a d
pe so al
ecomme datio s.
The
ew
ge e atio
of
platfo ms
is
attempti g
to
fo malise
that
ecosystem
by
addi g
ide tity
ve ificatio ,
digital
payme ts,
ati gs,
t ai i g,
i su a ce
a d
custome
suppo t.But
u like
food
delive y
o
ide-haili g,
these
se vices
i volve
somethi g
fa
mo e
i timate:
a
st a ge
e te i g
a
p ivate
home.That
has
fo ced
platfo ms
to
solve
a
u usually
difficult
p oblem.
They
must
simulta eously
p otect
wome
who
e te
u familia
homes
fo
wo k
a d
wome
who
may
be
home
alo e
whe
they
i vite
those
wo ke s
i side.The
esult
is
a
apidly
evolvi g
safety
a chitectu e
built
a ou d
backg ou d
checks,
est icted
se vice
hou s,
eal-time
mo ito i g,
SOS
systems,
huma
escalatio
teams
a d,
i c easi gly,
AI-assisted
isk
detectio .

Fo malisi g
t ust
i
a
i fo mal
wo kfo ce

I dia’s
domestic
wo k
secto
employs
millio s
of
wo ke s,
ma y
of
them
wome ,
a d
emai s
ove whelmi gly
i fo mal.
I sta t
domestic
help
platfo ms
have
c eated
ew
i come
oppo tu ities
by
offe i g
st uctu ed
o boa di g,
p edictable
payme ts
a d
access
to
a
la ge
custome
base.But
fo malisatio
has
also
b ought
safety
co ce s
i to
sha pe
focus.A
spokespe so
fo
P o to
sha ed
the
measu es
it
takes
to
e su e
t a spa e cy,
sayi g
that
eve y
wo ke
completes
c imi al
cou t
eco d
ve ificatio
a d
police
ve ificatio
befo e
joi i g
the
platfo m.
Custome s,
too,
ve ify
thei
ame,
pho e
umbe
a d
add ess
th ough
OTP
authe ticatio
a d
must
ag ee
to
a
code
of
co duct
befo e
placi g
a
booki g.P o to’s
wo ke s,
fo
example,
eceive
t ai i g
befo e
taki g
thei
fi st
assig me t,
a d
that
low
custome
ati gs
a e
i vestigated
by
t ai e s
athe
tha
t igge i g
automatic
deactivatio .“Eve y
hub
we
ope ate
doubles
as
a
t ai i g
ce t e,
a d
a
p ofessio al
takes
he
fi st
booki g
o ly
afte
she
is
t ai ed,
backg ou d-ve ified
a d
dispatch- eady,
a
p ocess
that
takes
about
fou
days,”
the
spokespe so
said.Simila ly,
S abbit,
whose
wo kfo ce
co sists
e ti ely
of
wome
p ofessio als,
said
it
has
built
a
multi-laye ed
safety
f amewo k
suppo ted
by
a
dedicated
T ust
&
Safety
team.A
spokespe so
said
the
system
i cludes
“ma dato y
KYC
a d
backg ou d
checks
fo
all
expe ts
o
the
platfo m,
ve ified
custome s,
add ess-level
t aceability
a d
co t olled
job
allocatio .”

Safety
vs
su veilla ce
divide

The
sha pest
divide
betwee
platfo ms
a d
custome s
is
eme gi g
a ou d
body-wo
came as.P o to
has
begu
expe ime ti g
with
optio al
eco ded
booki gs
desig ed
to
p otect
wo ke s
f om
false
allegatio s
i
cases
of
disputes
with
custome s.Fo
ma y
use s,
howeve ,
the
p ese ce
of
a
came a
i side
a
p ivate
home
cha ges
the
atu e
of
the
i te actio .
“I
k ow
some
platfo ms
a e
sta ti g
to
equip
thei
wo ke s
with
chest-mou ted
bodycams
fo
t a spa e cy,
a d
while
I
u de sta d
it
p otects
the
wo ke
f om
false
claims,
it
completely
f eaks
me
out
as
a
custome ,”
a
Delhi
eside t
said.“My
home
is
my
p ivate
sa ctua y.
The
idea
of
a
st a ge
walki g
th ough
my
livi g
oom
with
a
active
le s,
eco di g
the
exact
layout
of
my
home,
my
e t a ces,
my
exits,
my
pe so al
belo gi gs,
a d
whe e
my
wo k
setup
o
valuables
a e,
feels
like
a
ext eme
i vasio
of
p ivacy.”He
co ce s
exte d
beyo d
the
eco di g
itself.
“Whe e
is
that
video
footage
sto ed?
Who
at
the
tech
compa y
has
access
to
it?
Could
that
footage
leak
o
be
hacked?”
she
said.
“I
would
ho estly
thi k
twice
befo e
booki g
a
se vice
that
ma dates
live
video
eco di g
i side
my
p ivate
space.
The e
has
to
be
a
bou da y
betwee
physical
safety
a d
digital
su veilla ce.”P o to,
howeve ,
e su ed
that
the
sole
mecha ism
of
this
p ocess
is
to
e su e
safety
a d
p ivacy.It
said
that
additio al
video
data
is
collected
o ly
o
opt-i
ve ified
booki gs.
Acco di g
to
its
spokespe so ,
custome s
choose
the
featu e
du i g
booki g
a d
co fi m
it
agai
whe
the
wo ke
a ives.
The
came a
is
tilted
dow wa d
to
captu e
o ly
the
wo k
a ea,
eco ds
o
audio,
blu s
faces
a d
pe so al
i fo matio
o
the
device
itself,
deletes
aw
footage
immediately,
a d
etai s
o ly
a
a o ymised
e c ypted
ve sio
fo
a
limited
eview
pe iod
a d
AI
t ai i g.

Safety
by
desig

O e
of
the
most
st iki g
t e ds
ac oss
the
secto
is
that
ma y
safety
measu es
a e
desig ed
ot
a ou d
espo di g
to
i cide ts,
but
a ou d
p eve ti g
high- isk
situatio s
f om
a isi g
i
the
fi st
place.Seve al
platfo ms
have
est icted
se vice
hou s,
pa ticula ly
avoidi g
late-eve i g
a d
ight
booki gs
whe
wome
wo ke s
may
be
equi ed
to
e te
u familia
homes
afte
da k.S abbit
said
its
safety
system
mo ito s
active
jobs
i
eal
time
a d
ca
ide tify
a omalies
that
may
equi e
i te ve tio .
Acco di g
to
its
spokespe so ,
“Active
jobs
a e
mo ito ed
i
eal
time,
with
the
dedicated
T ust
&
Safety
team
suppo ti g
apid
escalatio
a d
i cide t
espo se.”

What
wome
check
befo e
ope i g
the
doo

Fo
ma y
wome ,
howeve ,
t ust
begi s
lo g
befo e
a
wo ke
a ives.A
24-yea -old
stude t
i
Jaipu
said
she
has
developed
a
co siste t
checklist
befo e
booki g
a y
o -dema d
domestic
se vice.
She
checks
whethe
the
app
displays
a
ve ified
p ofile
with
a
photog aph,
ID
ve ificatio ,
ati gs
a d
eviews,
a d
p efe s
platfo ms
that
offe
eal-time
t acki g
a d
OTP-based
se vice
ve ificatio .“The
fi st
thi g
I
check
is
whethe
the
app
shows
a
ve ified
p ofile
with
a
photo,
ID
ve ificatio ,
ati gs,
a d
eviews
f om
othe
wome ,”
she
said.
“Real-time
t acki g
a d
a
OTP-based
sta t
a d
e d
of
the
se vice
also
make
me
feel
mo e
comfo table.”Befo e
the
wo ke
a ives,
she
follows
a
set
of
p ecautio s
that
have
become
almost
automatic.
She
keeps
he
pho e
fully
cha ged,
i fo ms
at
least
o e
f ie d
that
someo e
is
comi g
ove ,
avoids
leavi g
valuables
o
pe so al
docume ts
i
plai
sight,
a d
stays
i
a
pa t
of
the
house
whe e
she
ca
easily
mo ito
what
is
happe i g.“I
usually
make
su e
my
pho e
is
fully
cha ged
a d
I
let
at
least
o e
f ie d
k ow
that
someo e
is
comi g
ove ,”
she
said.
“If
it’s
a
lo ge
se vice,
I
stay
i
a
pa t
of
the
house
whe e
I
ca
easily
see
what’s
happe i g.”She
is
also
ca eful
about
digital
p ivacy.
“I
p efe
apps
that
mask
pho e
umbe s,
a d
I
eve
sha e
ext a
details
u less
they’ e
ecessa y
fo
the
se vice,”
she
said.
“I
avoid
me tio i g
that
I
live
alo e
o
discussi g
my
schedule.
O ce
the
job
is
do e,
I’m
ca eful
ot
to
co ti ue
commu icatio
outside
the
platfo m.”Fo
he ,
safety
is
ot
just
about
p eve ti g
a
c ime;
it
is
about
mi imisi g
i fo matio
that
could
make
he
vul e able
late .

The
ituals
of
bei g
home
alo e

Mi al,
a
26-yea -old
p ofessio al
i
Delhi
desc ibed
a
diffe e t
set
of
habits
that
have
eme ged
th ough
epeated
use
of
i sta t
se vice
platfo ms.
While
the
age t
is
at
home,
she
stays
i
the
hall
athe
tha
a
closed
bed oom,
keeps
he
pho e
i
he
ha d,
a d
delibe ately
leaves
a
pai
of
he
pa t e ’s
o
male
flatmate’s
shoes
ea
the
e t a ce.“I
eve
sit
i
my
bed oom
with
the
doo
shut.
I
stay
i
the
mai
livi g
a ea,
usually
at
the
di i g
table
with
my
laptop,”
she
said.
“I
also
leave
a
pai
of
my
male
flatmate’s
o
pa t e ’s
shoes
ea
the
e t yway.
It’s
a
small
me tal
t ick,
but
it
makes
me
feel
less
exposed.”She
a d
two
close
f ie ds
have
a
i fo mal
safety
p otocol
built
a ou d
messagi g
apps.“I
have
a
p ivate
WhatsApp
g oup
with
two
close
f ie ds.
We
have
a
tacit
ule:
whe eve
a
i sta t
maid
o
epai
pe so
is
assig ed,
I
d op
the
t acki g
li k,
thei
ame,
a d
a
quick
‘Expected
time:
45
mi s,’”
she
said.
“I
do ’t
ove thi k
it,
but
it
gives
me
a
safety
et.”Whe
asked
what
app
featu es
actually
make
he
feel
secu e,
she
was
sceptical
of
ma keti g
labels.“Ho estly,
badges
a d
‘police
ve ified’
tags
o
a
app
sc ee
do ’t
mea
much
to
me
a ymo e.
A yo e
ca
upload
a
docume t,”
she
said.
“What
actually
makes
me
feel
safe
is
seei g
a
eal-time,
live
selfie
of
the
pe so
take
ight
whe
they
accept
the
job,
matchi g
the
photo
o
thei
p ofile.
Plus,
k owi g
the e’s
a
st ict
OTP
e t y
system
whe e
they
ca ’t
sta t
billi g
u til
I
give
them
a
code
at
the
doo .”He
disti ctio
is
impo ta t:
she
is
less
i te ested
i
histo ical
ve ificatio
a d
mo e
i te ested
i
eal-time
authe ticatio .

The
olde
custome ’s
defi itio
of
t ust

Fo
olde
use s,
digital
ve ificatio
ofte
feels
less
pe suasive
tha
physical
ve ificatio .Sa ita,
a
52-yea -old
homemake
i
Delhi-NCR,
said
she
places
g eate
t ust
i
ta gible
i dicato s
such
as
u ifo ms,
ide tity
ca ds
a d
eside tial
secu ity
systems.“A
p ofessio al
ow
gets
to
sha e
he
ve sio
of
eve ts
a d
a y
eleva t
i fo matio
befo e
a
decisio
is
take ,
a d
we
wo k
to
keep
i vestigatio s
bala ced
a d
t a spa e t,”
P o to
spokespe so
said.That
shift,
f om
t eati g
wo ke s
me ely
as
se vice
p ovide s
to
t eati g
them
as
ights-bea i g
pa ticipa ts
i
the
platfo m
ecosystem,
may
p ove
as
impo ta t
as
a y
tech ological
i ovatio .

The
ext
phase
of
t ust

As
i sta t
domestic
help
se vices
expa d
beyo d
met opolita
cities
i to
smalle
u ba
ce t es,
safety
may
become
the
i dust y’s
p ima y
competitive
diffe e tiato .Speed
is
easy
to
adve tise.
T ust
is
ha de
to
build.Wome
a e
aski g
fo
featu es
that
combi e
digital
ve ificatio
with
huma
accou tability:
live
ide tity
co fi matio ,
female-wo ke
filte s,
t usted-co tact
otificatio s,
eside tial
gate
i teg atio ,
disc eet
exit
mecha isms,
eighbou hood-level
eputatio
a d
t a spa e t
data
gove a ce.Platfo ms,
mea while,
a e
i vesti g
i
t ai i g
hubs,
backg ou d
ve ificatio ,
est icted
se vice
hou s,
SOS
etwo ks,
cou selli g,
i su a ce
a d
AI-assisted
mo ito i g.

Go to Sou ce